HardiePlank fiber cement versus vinyl siding
While both HardiePlank siding and vinyl siding can mimic the look of natural siding, Hardiplank bears the closest resemblance to wood. Both the manufacturing and installation process of HardiePlank siding is designed to allow for slight irregularities and surface luster that matches wood products. The process of making and disposing of HardiePlank fiber cement siding is eco-friendly since the panels are primarily made of wood paste, whereas vinyl requires the use of fossil fuels.
Both materials are durable options, but HardiePlank siding has one disadvantage: it absorbs moisture. While moisture accumulation is something to keep in mind, Hardiplank comes with unbeatable warranties to ease any concerns and is repaired more easily than vinyl.
If you’re most concerned with a natural appearance, better curb appeal, eco-friendliness or fire-resistance, HardiePlank siding is the best choice.
If you’re looking for a siding option that’s more affordable and available with a layer of energy-saving insulation, look into our vinyl house siding.
Cost of HardiePlank house siding replacement in Wisconsin
HardiePlank siding usually costs between $1.15 and $2.00 per square foot. Labor costs are typically more than vinyl because HardiePlank requires more workers, takes longer to install and needs more planning.
There’s no set price on house siding replacement because costs will depend on the size of your house and the brand of HardiePlank that you choose. Contact Infinity for a free cost estimate.
Infinity Exteriors is your best choice for residential & commercial siding installation
There is no siding installation company in the state offering better siding products, greater siding installation expertise, special offers, payment plans, lifetime warranties, or a better overall value.
Our siding installation experts have locations in Appleton, Madison, and Milwaukee, and are able to service any of the surrounding areas. No matter where you are in Wisconsin, we can come to you.
Visit our interactive remodeling map to see if your neighbors are Infinity Exteriors customers.
Reviews from Satisfied Customers

Debbie Moczyns
Tom has been great to work with through the process of choosing windows and siding. I would recommend him to others.
Tom has been great to work with through the process of choosing windows and siding. I would recommend him to others.
Elysha Lamping
Vin really knew his stuff and was able to make the process very thorough and simple at the same time. He went above and beyond with his service, helping secure some siding while he was inspecting the roof damage to help prevent leaks. We loved his energy, passion and recommendations! Communication w...
Vin really knew his stuff and was able to make the process very thorough and simple at the same time. He went above and beyond with his service, helping secure some siding while he was inspecting the roof damage to help prevent leaks. We loved his energy, passion and recommendations! Communication was also very timely and easy to understand. You can tell Vin and his team have a ton of experience and have really fine tuned their processes to benefit their customer. They also back their quality which is a huge benefit of working with them.
Read More
Roby Skrbis
Had a great experience with Infinity Exteriors from start to finish. Worked with a few different staff members but with Caleb and Jake the most who were both fantastic. We needed our siding replaced due to cracking and buckling etc. Every meeting we had with the team that supported us was comfortabl...
Had a great experience with Infinity Exteriors from start to finish. Worked with a few different staff members but with Caleb and Jake the most who were both fantastic. We needed our siding replaced due to cracking and buckling etc. Every meeting we had with the team that supported us was comfortable, easy, and informative. Highly recommend using Infinity for your needs.
Read More
Debbie Moczyns
Tom has been great to work with through the process of choosing windows and siding. I would recommend him to others.
Tom has been great to work with through the process of choosing windows and siding. I would recommend him to others.
Elysha Lamping
Vin really knew his stuff and was able to make the process very thorough and simple at the same time. He went above and beyond with his service, helping secure some siding while he was inspecting the roof damage to help prevent leaks. We loved his energy, passion and recommendations! Communication w...
Vin really knew his stuff and was able to make the process very thorough and simple at the same time. He went above and beyond with his service, helping secure some siding while he was inspecting the roof damage to help prevent leaks. We loved his energy, passion and recommendations! Communication was also very timely and easy to understand. You can tell Vin and his team have a ton of experience and have really fine tuned their processes to benefit their customer. They also back their quality which is a huge benefit of working with them.
Read More
Roby Skrbis
Had a great experience with Infinity Exteriors from start to finish. Worked with a few different staff members but with Caleb and Jake the most who were both fantastic. We needed our siding replaced due to cracking and buckling etc. Every meeting we had with the team that supported us was comfortabl...
Had a great experience with Infinity Exteriors from start to finish. Worked with a few different staff members but with Caleb and Jake the most who were both fantastic. We needed our siding replaced due to cracking and buckling etc. Every meeting we had with the team that supported us was comfortable, easy, and informative. Highly recommend using Infinity for your needs.
Read More
Debbie Moczyns
Tom has been great to work with through the process of choosing windows and siding. I would recommend him to others.
Tom has been great to work with through the process of choosing windows and siding. I would recommend him to others.
Elysha Lamping
Vin really knew his stuff and was able to make the process very thorough and simple at the same time. He went above and beyond with his service, helping secure some siding while he was inspecting the roof damage to help prevent leaks. We loved his energy, passion and recommendations! Communication w...
Vin really knew his stuff and was able to make the process very thorough and simple at the same time. He went above and beyond with his service, helping secure some siding while he was inspecting the roof damage to help prevent leaks. We loved his energy, passion and recommendations! Communication was also very timely and easy to understand. You can tell Vin and his team have a ton of experience and have really fine tuned their processes to benefit their customer. They also back their quality which is a huge benefit of working with them.
Read More
